2009
Miriah Childers, South Caldwell High School
Elizabeth Hughes, Hibriten High School
Caitlin Adams, Hibriten High School

2008
Lauren Livingston, Hibriten High School
Telea Dula, West Caldwell High School
Kristin Greene, South Caldwell High School

2007
Shatericka Warren, West Caldwell High School
Brittany Kirby, South Caldwell High School
amber Walsh, Hibriten High School